| ROUND | R1 | R2 | QF | SF | ||||
| l1 | l2 | l1 | l2 | l1 | l2 | l1 | l2 | |
| Season archive |
| Tuesday, 6 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 |  Comunicaciones | 1-4 | Monterrey | ||
| 29 | Mejía | 22 | Berterame | ||
| 51 | González | ||||
| 71 | Gallardo | ||||
| 85 | Aguirre | ||||
| r1l1 |  Real Estelí | 2-1 | América | ||
| 7(p) | Bonilla | 90 | Quiñones | ||
| 47 | Fletes | ||||
| Wednesday, 7 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 |  Vancouver Whitecaps | 1-1 | Tigres | ||
| 32 | Kreilach | 88 | Gignac | ||
| r1l1 |  Herediano | 1-2 | Toluca | ||
| 88 | Vega | 16 | Pereira | ||
| 59 | Morales | ||||
| r1l1 |  Forge | 1-3 | Guadalajara | ||
| 31 | Campbell | 26 | Cowell | ||
| 45 | Marín | ||||
| 63 | Cowell | ||||
| Wednesday, 14 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 | Guadalajara | 2-1 | Forge | ||
| 8 | Gutierrez | 90 | Tavernier | ||
| 62 | Castillo | ||||
| Tuesday, 20 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 | Saprissa | 2-3 | Philadelphia Union | ||
| 28(og) | Glesnes | 55 | Carranza | ||
| 90 | Taylor | 76 | Carranza | ||
| 79 | Carranza | ||||
| r1l1 | St. Louis CITY SC | 2-1 | Houston Dynamo | ||
| 61 | Parker | 72 | Kowalczyk | ||
| 90 | Kijima | ||||
| Wednesday, 21 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 |  Independiente | 0-1 | New England Revolution | ||
| 54 | Chancalay | ||||
| Thursday, 22 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 |  Cavalier | 0-2 | FC Cincinnati | ||
| 45 | Santos | ||||
| 87 | Pinto | ||||
| Friday, 23 February 2024 | |||||
| r1l1 |  Moca | 0-3 | Nashville | ||
| 12 | Mukhtar | ||||
| 25 | Surridge | ||||
| 75 | Boyd | ||||
| 3 | +3 | Julián CARRANZA (Philadelphia Union) |
| 2 | +2 | Cade COWELL (Guadalajara) |
| 1 | +1 | José CASTILLO (Guadalajara) |
| +1 | Malik PINTO (FC Cincinnati) | |
| +1 | Julian QUIÑONES (América) | |
| +1 | Kevaughn TAVERNIER (Forge) | |
| +1 | Andrés PEREIRA (Toluca) | |
| +1 | Arturo GONZÁLEZ (Monterrey) | |
| +1 | Hany MUKHTAR (Nashville) | |
| +1 | Rodrigo AGUIRRE (Monterrey) | |
| +1 | Carlos MEJÍA (Comunicaciones) | |
| +1 | Sergio SANTOS (FC Cincinnati) | |
| +1 | Ricardo MARÍN (Guadalajara) | |
| +1 | Robert MORALES (Toluca) | |
| +1 | Sam SURRIDGE (Nashville) | |
| +1 | Gerald TAYLOR (Saprissa) | |
| +1 | Tyler BOYD (Nashville) | |
| +1 | Deyver VEGA (Herediano) | |
| +1 | Jesús GALLARDO (Monterrey) | |
| +1 | Byron BONILLA (Real Estelí, 1p) | |
| +1 | Hosei KIJIMA (St. Louis CITY SC) | |
| +1 | Damir KREILACH (Vancouver Whitecaps) | |
| +1 | Terran CAMPBELL (Forge) | |
| +1 | Germán BERTERAME (Monterrey) | |
| +1 | Marvin FLETES (Real Estelí) | |
| +1 | Tomás CHANCALAY (New England Revolution) | |
| +1 | Sebastian KOWALCZYK (Houston Dynamo) | |
| +1 | Tim PARKER (St. Louis CITY SC) | |
| +1 | André-Pierre GIGNAC (Tigres) | |
| +1 | Erick GUTIERREZ (Guadalajara) |
