| ||||||||||||||||||||
| Saturday, 14 November 2009 | ||||||
| l1 | Costa Rica | 0-1 | Uruguay | |||
| Wednesday, 18 November 2009 | ||||||
| l2 | Uruguay | 1-1 | Costa Rica | 2-1 | ||
| 7 | Carlos PAVÓN (Honduras) |
| Luton SHELTON (Jamaica) | |
| 6 | Jozy ALTIDORE (United States) |
| Carlos COSTLY (Honduras) | |
| Carlos RUIZ (Guatemala) | |
| Bryan RUIZ (Costa Rica) | |
| Álvaro SABORIO (Costa Rica) | |
| Eliseo QUINTANILLA (El Salvador) | |
| Ali GERBA (Canada) | |
| 5 | Michael BRADLEY (United States) |
| Brian CHING (United States) | |
| Celso BORGES (Costa Rica) | |
| Landon DONOVAN (United States) | |
| Clint DEMPSEY (United States) | |
| 4 | Julío DE LEÓN (Honduras) |
| Keon DANIEL (Trinidad & Tobago) | |
| Walter CENTENO (Costa Rica) | |
| 3 | Jared BORGETTI (Mexico) |
| Kerry BAPTISTE (Trinidad & Tobago) | |
| Andrés GUARDADO (Mexico) | |
| Ramón NÚÑEZ (Honduras) | |
| Carlos VELA (Mexico) | |
| Fernando ARCE (Mexico) | |
| Dwight YORKE (Trinidad & Tobago) | |
| Armando ALONSO (Costa Rica) | |
| Pavel PARDO (Mexico) | |
| David SUAZO (Honduras) | |
| Cuauhtémoc BLANCO (Mexico) |